This is sooo good. It will make you smack your Momma. Don’t wait till winter to try this one. I found this in a e-book called Slow Cookin’ Secrets. I used a chuck roast last time I made it . This time I used a Chuck tender roast. Both work well. I also used McCormick pot Roast mix instead of onion soup mix and I added a few baby yukon gold potatoes. try this you won’t regret it.